The 10 Must-Watch Psychological Scary Movies on Netflix

Last Updated on May 17, 2024 by Fangoria Editor

Are you in a spooky mood and searching for a good thriller that's not an entire slasher film? We got you covered. Recently someone asked, โ€œWhat is the scariest movie you watched on Netflix. What is the most adult, legit frightening film?โ€

They continued, โ€œTrying to have a good movie night, and we want to be terrified but worried I'll end up watching something cheesy. Preferably not gore, but more psychological and twisted.โ€ The internet responded with these scariest movies and miniseries on Netflix.

  • Incantation (2022)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    For Either_Importance627 Incantation, โ€œwas a movie that legit made me believe I was getting a black magic spell put on me. You'll understand if you watch it.โ€

    ElaineBenesKennedyJR added, โ€œDefinitely, the scariest I've watched in a long while.โ€

    Another user noted, โ€œI can't believe this is so far down. It's the scariest movie on Netflix right now!โ€

  • Creep (2014)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    โ€œMany good ones have already been mentioned,โ€ Bison90ย  wrote, โ€œso I'll throw a wildcard out and say Creepย andย Creep 2. They are fun and had me sweating/uncomfortable in most of both films. The best part is their run times are 77 and 80 minutes, so back-to-back is pretty easy.โ€

    Redditor Tinybrownsparrow added, โ€œThese were great. I was impressed with how well the movies created compelling suspense with surprisingly simple elements.โ€

  • Marianne (2019)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    Marianne is a French horror miniseries following a young novelist realizing that the characters she writes about in her horror novels are also in the real world.

  • The Old Ways (2020)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    The Old Ways is a folk horror film following a Mexican-American reporter returning to her hometown near Veracruz, Mexico, searching for a story on witchcraft. However, the locals and bruja (female practitioner of witchcraft) kidnaps her, believing her to be possessed by a demon.โ€

  • His House (2020)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    Anoelr1963 replied, โ€œHis House. A refugee couple makes a harrowing escape from war-torn South Sudan. However, they struggle to adjust to their new life in an English town with evil lurking beneath the surface. So good, great ending.โ€

  • The Conjuring 2 (2016)

    Image Credit: Warner Bros. Pictures.

    Pollo_de_mar answered, โ€œConjuring 2ย was scary to me because it gave me the feeling that these events were real. So I could only watch about 20 minutes at a time and then step away and come back later.โ€ Workthrow3 admitted, โ€œThe entireย Conjuringย series and theย Annabelleย series surprised me because they're super entertaining and scary.โ€

  • It Follows (2014)

    Image Credit: RADiUS-TWC.

    Innocent_not admitted, โ€œA long time ago, I saw a movie namedย It Follows. Very creepy, indeed.โ€ Mightbedylan agreed, โ€œThis is my favorite horror movie of all time. Excellent stuff, and it has a great soundtrack.โ€

  • Hush (2016)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    Power_Blonde answered, โ€œHushย is more suspense than scary/horror. However, I enjoyed it because it's scarier. After all, a situation like that could happen. It was a great late-night watch in the dark one weekend for me.โ€

  • The Ritual (2017)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    KeriEatsSouls stated, โ€œThe Ritualย was genuinely creepy at times.โ€ EleanorRigorMortis agreed, โ€œI haven't been that creeped out since The Blair Witch Project.โ€

    Catwoman1948 replied, โ€œSame here.ย The Ritualย was very creepy, very original. And didn't wimp out on The Monster!ย The Blair Witch scareย hits you after watching it, and you are terrified.โ€

  • Haunting of Hill House (2018)

    Image Credit: Netflix.

    Lottalicious answered, โ€œIf you don't mind watching a series instead,ย The Haunting of Hill Houseย is a phenomenal experience!โ€ Hamptont2010 agreed, โ€œIt might be my single favorite piece of horror media ever produced. Of course, I also loveย The Haunting of Bly Manorย (2020), but it's almost more of a love story with horror elements.โ€

    This article originally appeared on Wealth of Geeks.